ACLU of Vermont v. Essex County Sheriff’s Department

  • Filed: Jun 3, 2024
  • Latest Update: Nov 17, 2026
visa and badge

Summary


When local police get mixed up in the business of immigration enforcement, civil rights violations are the inevitable result. The Essex County Sheriff’s Department has wrongfully withheld records related to its engagement with immigration officials, which is why we have taken them to court.

Sheriff’s comments on immigration enforcement prompts public records request

In 2023, the Vermont Criminal Justice Council considered several revisions to the state’s model policy that would close lingering loopholes that we and Migrant Justice found still undermined trust between Vermont’s immigrant community and police. It was these proposed changes that prompted Essex County Sheriff Trevor Colby to publicly express his concerns that the amended FIPP would supposedly stymie his officers’ ability to do their jobs.

According to a December 2023 article published by Community Service News, Sheriff Colby “emphasized that his priority is to keep residents within his jurisdiction safe, and people in his relatively remote part of the state get shaken up when they see unfamiliar folks. Up there, he said, everyone basically knows everyone.” As a result, Colby reportedly explained that he “would likely call immigration authorities after a traffic stop if he thought the people in the car were undocumented.”

Such a call would likely violate the FIPP and, if based on race or other protected categories, could also violate the constitution. Sheriff Colby’s statement—especially worrying in light of the incoming Trump administration’s mass deportation agenda—prompted us to file a public records request in January 2024 seeking the Essex County Sheriff Department’s records relating to immigration enforcement.

Sheriff’s department fails to comply with Vermont Public Records Act

Following months of back and forth over the scope of our request, the Department declined to provide copies of the records as required by state law. Instead, they insisted that the ACLU travel to the sheriff’s office in Guildhall to “inspect” the records in person before staff would make copies of them. Such a requirement would violate Vermont’s open records laws, which guarantee the public access to public records.

As a result, we sued the Sheriff’s Department to obtain copies of the records in question and are asking the court to clarify that the Sheriff’s Department’s interpretation of the law is incorrect.

Documents


Where it started

Learn More About the Issues in This Case